close

Log-in here for All Access Areas >

forgotten password? Get your free VOX pass >

 

VOX | Discussion Forums » VOX Amplifiers » Valvetronix+ & Valvetronix

 

VT40+ Hiss - Possible Resolution

Started 1 year ago by wbesack

Topic Rating:


 

wbesack

Member

 

I am on my second VT40+ as my first one died after 8 months. Thank you Vox Warranty!!! I got a free replacement with new warranty but had to pay for shipping.

On to more important issues. The dreaded HISS. I never noticed the hiss that has plagued so many VT+ models...until now. Granted, I don't usually play it very loud and it is normal for me to have the Master knob around the 10 o'clock position and the Power knob around 9 o'clock.

Recently I started noticing an annoying hiss that trailed off after playing notes. It was especially noticeable if I lightly struck my low E string. Seems like the lower the note, the worse the hiss was. Brushing my high e produced only a mild barely noticeable trailing hiss. This being my 4th Valvetronix and having just purchased the Joe Webb's effects loop mod kit (not installed yet), I was really ticked off to say the least.

I started doing some experimenting. I changed power outlets, cords, etc.. I played a lot with the Master and Power knobs. What I found is this:

More Gain = worse hiss (which seems obvious)
More Master = worse hiss
More Power = worse hiss
Master vs. Power (high Master with low Power vs. low Master with high Power = no difference
Overall Volume as a result of the combination of Master and Power: higher overall volume = worse hiss
Presets vs. Hiss: Some built-in presets are worse than others.
Noise Reduction: BINGO! This seems to have a HUGE effect on the problem

I never messed with the noise reduction settings before. It's possible my son messed with it recently but it's such an obscure process to access it, I didn't think much of it. Per the manual, noise reduction is set individually for each program or manual mode. What I noticed about the hiss was that it was very artificial sounding the way it trailed off. When I started messing with it, I found that all the way on to the right was terrible sounding (NR on maximum). All the way to the left (NR off) and the hiss was bad. If you turn the knob up just barely, you will hear an audible change when the NR system engages.

It's very similar to when you use one of the Pedal effect and turn the "Value" knob up slightly from the left (off) position. You hear an audible change as soon as the effect is ON.

What I found was that the hiss seemed to be minimized with the NR in this "barely on" state. The audio quality is preserved but the hiss is minimal. When the NR was in the fully off position, the hiss was horrible. Eventually I was able to get it fairly clean with the AC30TB model in manual, dials all at the 12 o'clock position, and the Master and Power knobs also at the 12 o'clock position. Some slight hiss like any other cranked amp, but the trailing hiss seemed minimal at best. Certainly livable if you're outside your return period.

Since I never noticed this problem before, I am considering doing a factory reset since that wipes both user presets AND resets the factory NR settings. I'll post how it goes. Let me know if anyone else can duplicate my results, either good or bad.


Posted 1 year ago

 

wbesack

Member

 

REVISED: I made a mistake. My testing was flawed. I wasn't engaging the NR when I thought I was, it was engaging one of the tube effects. Ooops. What I did find was the NR at low to moderate levels was somewhat effective at reducing the hiss, especially at lower gain and power levels, but with the NR anywhere beyond half way and the notes started getting all warbally, almost a vibe effect. In the end, I found that as long as I don't run the Gain, Master, and Power knobs at 12:00 or higher (all together at one time) I can nearly eliminate the hiss. I can exceed the 12 o'clock position on any 1 knob as long as I compensate by lowering one of the other knobs to 9 or so. For example, I can run the Gain at 10, the Master at 10, and the Power at 3 o'clock and I'm fine. Or I can turn up the Gain to 1 or 2 as long as I keep the Master and Power around 9 or 10. It's possible my amp always had this issue but I never turn it up that loud to notice.

I need to find another 40+ at a local store and see if I can duplicate my findings. I had a chrome front VT15 that I sold to buy the 40+. Now I'm wishing I'd kept it. Might be time to visit Craigslist and say goodby to the 40+.

What's really interesting is that I have a Boss FA-1 FET pre-amplifier pedal (clone) that can boost volume significantly. It can be used to really slam the tube. I expected that using that would cause my clean amp settings to start hissing when the volume or drive was driven up with the pedal. I set the amp with gain, master, and power settings that gave no hiss, then I engaged the FA-1 pedal and started turning up the volume. Still no hiss, or if there were any, it was barely noticeable, but I was getting a lot more volume and a bit of crunchy drive.


Posted 1 year ago

 

wbesack

Member

 

More testing and more confirmation. If you have issues with hissing on the VT+ line, do the following:

1. Reset factory defaults. Make sure you make note of any settings for any presets you created as THIS WILL WIPE THEM OUT!!! Resetting restores the noise reduction settings, just in case you got them out of whack. To reset to factory defaults, turn off the amp. Hold down preset buttons 1 and 4. Turn on the amp while holding down buttons 1 and 4. When the preset lights start blinking, press the Tap button and release it. All the lights on the top will flash for a few seconds, then it's done. Just like the day you brought it home. Instructions are in the VT40+ manual on page 16.

2. Learn to compensate when using the Gain, Master, and Power knobs. THIS IS THE MOST IMPORTANT PART TO MANAGING HISS. If you need extra gain, turn it up to 2 or 3 and turn the Master and/or Power knobs to something around or below 10 o'clock. If you want more output, crank up the Master or Power knobs to 12 o'clock or more, but keep in mind that you will need to turn down the Gain (maybe Volume) to something around 9 o'clock. It didn't take me long to figure out how to balance the 3 controls (4 if you include the Volume knob which might also have an impact). In no time, I had a clean sounding amp again. The only limitation is that you aren't going to be able to run the amp at gigging volumes without a mic and expect it to be crystal clear and noise free. If you want loud and clear, you'll have to put a mic on the amp. It does seem to run at normal "home" volumes without noise if you follow my steps above.

For what it's worth, I have not touched the noise reduction settings after I did the factory reset. I recommend you do the same unless you know what you're doing and have a good reason to do so.


Posted 1 year ago

 

 

That's very interesting. I have a VT20+ and a VT30. The hiss is much more obnoxious on the VT20+. On low gain clean amp models, I don't find that the NR does anything except ruin the sustain, so I keep it turned off. The vast majority of the hiss comes from the power amp section, so Gain and Volume don't contribute much unless you crank them way up.

Adding a pre-amp in front of the Gain control, though, would be the same as turning up the Gain wouldn't it? If you increase the gain using a preamp into the input, don't you then have to turn the Gain knob down to keep it clean, just as you would if you used a higher output guitar pickup?

I have a Boosta Grande so I'll try this out when I have a chance, but it's hard for me to see how it would be any different.

BTW, the AC30TB model is noisier than any of the other clean models - I found it useful in the earlier Valvetronix amps, don't like it on the VT+.

The other issue I have with your advice is that with all Valvetronix amps, the tone takes a hit if you lower the PL and MV controls. The sweet spot for MV is around 1:30-3:00 as it drives the tube nicely. The PL, in spite of what Vox would have us believe, is nowhere close to transparent and always sounds better turned up to 1:30 or so, higher on the earlier ones. This was not a problem in the AD series or the VT series as the hiss only becomes audible in the last 1/4 turn of the PL knob, and MV had little effect on hiss. Unfortunately, in the VT+, I have to put up with hiss to get decent tone, even with those controls lower than I would like.

I would never recommend using the VT+ to record, at least not the 20+ or the 40+. The higher priced ones may, according to posts by some of their owners, have less hiss due to higher quality power amp parts, and so may be more useful for recording. OTOH, my VT30 is stellar in both high and low volume situations.


Posted 1 year ago

 

voxman

VOX Forum Moderator

voxman
 

What's really interesting is that I have a Boss FA-1 FET pre-amplifier pedal (clone) that can boost volume significantly. It can be used to really slam the tube.

I think you're possibly getting a bit confused when you say 'slam the tube' ? Pedals of this type are designed to boost the pre-amp section of an amp. In the Valvetronix, the pre-amp is entirely digital. The tube is in the power-amp section.

The only way to push the tube in your Valvetronix is to raise up the Master Volume. No external pedal can 'slam the tube' in your Valvetronix (by which I think you mean 'push' for greater tube saturation). Any effect you're hearing is from boosting the digital pre-amp section, not the power amp section.

Good article on the FA1FET here which might be of interest:

http://musicgear-reviews.com/tools-accessories/boss-fa1-fet-amplifier/

you'll note that it says :

" If you’re playing a solid-state amplifier or most digital amp modelers, you won’t really benefit from this pretty cool tone feature "

And:

" briefly, sending more volume into your clean valve amp than it has headroom, will overdrive the pre-amp stage of your amplifier, producing the pre-amp to clip and produce what is widely known as ‘natural overdrive.’ ‘Natural Overdrive’ as opposed to the more common way of adding distortion by using dedicated effects pedals. "


Posted 1 year ago

 

wbesack

Member

 

Thanks for the info voxman and cosmicrepairdude. I did misunderstand. I thought I was pushing the tube with the FA-1. Hitting the digital pre-amp with the FA-1, adjusting the FA-1 volume level does give me everything from a clean boost with a bit of thickness on up to a decent amount of clipping, kind of a mild Tube Screamer sound. I thought this was somewhat the sound benefit I was looking for from the FA-1. It's definitely different that what I could get with my TS9 or TS808 on light settings.

Speaking of external pedals, are they detrimental to an amp like this, especially the FA-1 which sends boosted volume into the amp?? I have a Joe Webb effects loop kit that I have not yet installed.

I just started getting this snare noise in the last few weeks and I feel sick to my stomach about it. I just completed the expensive cleaning process with Deoxit and disassembly of every friction contact point inside, including the tube. No change. The AC30TB is the worst and being a U2 fan, is the model I almost always need. I suppose I could try and get by with the AC15 model but I bought this amp for its AC30TB capability. Until recently, I don't recall ever having a problem with it.

Can either of you explain why I don't seem to have a snare problem when using headphones? Even the AC30TB sounds pretty good and seems to be void of the snare when using headphones.


Posted 1 year ago

 

wbesack

Member

 

I realize that perhaps I should start a new thread for this but since we are on the subject of the FA-1...

I was just reading the FA-1 article in more detail. I posted this information there as well but would like your take on it given your expertise with Valvetronix and all things Vox.

I built and use a FA-1 clone that is identical in every component to the original. So essentially I'm using a pre-amp pedal to drive the solid state pre-amp, right? I have questions about if this is really giving me what a real tube user might get.

I can tell you for sure that I can get great tone control with the bass and treble dials on the FA-1. Also, I can use the volume knob on FA-1 to get fairly clean volume boost around 9 o'clock and mild grit and slight thickness around 10 o'clock. If I crank the volume to around 12 or 1 o'clock, I can get some decent overdrive. Pushing the volume higher and I get significant clipping. It's kind of like a mild TS9, but different. More grit than tube sound. Very clean with the ability to adjust bass and treble. I have a TS9 and TS808 and regardless of how I adjust them, I can not simulate what the FA-1 does.

So my question is, am I getting the desired result? Is this the same type of response someone with an actual AC30TB is going to get with this FA-1 pedal? If so, how could this be working with a solid state pre-amp? Is it possible that the digital pre-amp and/or AC30TB modeling is accurately reacting to the FA-1?


Posted 1 year ago

 

wbesack

Member

 

So I did some more testing. I can run the MV up at 1:30 to 3:00 but I have to leave the PL at 9:00 or below. I also have to make sure the gain is somewhere left of 12:00. These settings make the snare noise nearly inaudible with all other knobs straight up. If I bump the volume or treble past 12, snare creeps in. But if what you tell me is true, I'm robbing myself of tone with the PL that low. I think my ears would be bleeding if I turned up the PL to 1:30 with the ML at 3:00....and the snare hiss would be off the chart.

Adding the FA-1 lets me maybe get a bit more volume out of it but as you suggested, I have to back off the gain unless I'm looking for that grit. So I'm no expert but is using the FA-1 that pushes a higher volume signal into the amp really just doing exactly the same as turning up the gain a bit? I hope I didn't spend a lot of money and time to build a pedal that just substitutes the gain knob. It seems like there would have to be a slight difference in sound, aside from the ability to EQ using the bass and treble knobs on the pedal.

As I mentioned, I used to have an AD15VT and a VT15 prior to this. I actually liked the AD15VT better than the VT15 tone wise. Never tried the VT30. GC's got a used VT30 for $150. Maybe it's time to throw in the towel and put this 40+ up on Craigslist. Is the VT30 a reliable quality sounding unit in AC30TB mode? My VT15 sounded a bit thin but probably due to the speaker size. I also didn't like the restriction of using only one effect at a time but I don't use internal effects anymore.


Posted 1 year ago

 

voxman

VOX Forum Moderator

voxman
 

External pedals won't harm your amp.

Forget about the technicalities - if you like the tone, that's all that matters. You will get better tone if you raise up the power-selector - it's an attenuator and although Vox says its totally transparent, it isn't....there is some loss of tone. You need the power selector at least open 25-30%.

Your FA1 is adding a boost which might be giving a bit fuller tone, so it's not quite the same as adding gain.

I liked the VT30 (see my you-tube demo's). Whilst it doesn't have the pedal section and has less amp models, I actually preferred it tonally to the VT40+. But your VT40+ just seems to b suffering from dirty sockets.


Posted 1 year ago

 

 

No, your ears wouldn't be bleeding because you should be using the Volume control to turn down the loudness. Leave the Treble at 12 or below.

Regarding bass and treble: do those knobs on the FA-1 have a different effect than the same knobs on the amp itself or do they do pretty much the same thing? If the latter, then your FA-1 is just duplicating things you could be doing on your amp.

I already told you what I think of the AC30TB model - I think it sounded much better on both my original AD15VT and my VT30, but that's just my opinion. BTW, my rave reviews on the VT30 are dependent on having added acoustic insulation to the cabinet. There are threads on that, which I can direct you to, if you're interested.

And as I have pointed out on the snare noise thread, people who have the problem can't get rid of it by turning knobs or changing models, as far as I can tell. Some models are noisier than others (like the AC30TB) but that's not snare noise. As I also said there, you have to test for it with Noise Reduction (noise gate) off.

One more question regarding the hiss/noise issue you raised here: are you using single coil or humbucking pickups?


Posted 1 year ago

 

lusthaben

Member

 

Does anyone remember a recent thread which suggested that the tube may be the culprit? . . .that there was a coating on the pins???

Whatever became of that theory?


Posted 1 year ago

 

 

In my view, the tube is one of many areas where the anti-oxidant coating can screw things up.
http://www.voxamps.com/forum/topic.php?id=3716&page=20
About half way down the page:
The procedure mentioned lower down that page [19] involving the tube pins and speaker connectors won't necessarily do the trick for everyone because several people earlier on in this thread replaced the tube with a brand new one and it didn't help, and others have reported that they hear the snare noise through headphones which would eliminate speaker connections (and the tube) as the problem.
I believe that the problem can come from any of several connections which is why I think all connections should be cleaned, not just 2.


Posted 1 year ago

 

wbesack

Member

 

Thank you both for the input. I'm so happy this forum exists. Sorry cosmic, I should have put it more in the form of a question. I was looking more for confirmation that moving to a VT30 would give me a quality AC30TB model assuming I do the insulation mod, since you own one. That would probably let me still use my JoeWebb effects loop mod for my delay and reverb pedals, better headphone jack, etc.. Otherwise, I'd better be looking for a Class A tube amp in my price range. Maybe the new AC4C1-BL, AC4TV or an AC15.

I understand you're happy with your VT30 and the AC30TB model is horribly noisy on the VT40+ by default. And yes, all my testing is done with the noise reduction turned off. I have tested with both single and humbucking pickups as well as coil tapped guitar. Moving from single or tapped pickups to humbucker does reduce the general noise that is associated with any amp, but has no major effect on reducing the snare noise other than it darkens up a bit which sort of masks it.

I'll have to try playing around with the Volume knob. It's always been a bit unclear to me the order in which I should set the V, MV, and PL. I typically set the V and MV, then use the PL to adjust overall volume. If I understand you correctly, set the MV and PL to around 1:30 if possible without too much snare, then turn down the V to set overall volume?

But getting back to this thread....sorry....and for lusthaben's benefit...I did do a thorough cleaning, including the tube and sockets, speaker connectors, etc. I did not replace the speaker connectors since it is still on warranty. I may make up a new speaker cable just to test it out but I don't think that is worth the effort or will make a difference. Hopefully lusthaben, the process fixes yours. I may try it again but I don't have much hope that it will work. Maybe I'll trace the circuit back from the PL pot and see if there's anything else I missed.

In my case, the problem does not seem to occur when headphones are used. I know that others have a different experience. Since the PL attenuator has no effect when headphones are used, does that suggest it's in that attenuator itself or at least that circuit? I wonder what other components might be in that circuit that might be replaceable. Replacing all the capacitors would be cheap and easy but certainly void the warranty. Not sure what other chips, op-amp's, etc. might be in there that could be replaced. I'm sure Vox knows the likely sources. Too bad they can't just share the info. Pretty sad when my JamVOX does a cleaner job modeling an AC30TB than a real amp.


Posted 1 year ago

 

wbesack

Member

 

BTW, further testing this morning with the FA-1... it seemed like the sound it adds is slightly different than what the Gain control adds and in some ways, gave me a bit more volume and gain to work with to compensate for my need to keep the amp's gain and PL lower to avoid the snare. The amp's Gain is smoother and more refined than what the FA-1 provides. Turning the gain down a bit and bumping up the volume on the FA-1 gives a slightly thicker sound with some grit. I'm not familiar with a Boosta Grande but I'd be curious what results you have with it going into a Valvetronix digital pre-amp. Like with the tone knob on a TS9, the bass and treble knobs on the FA-1 sort of determine the color of the FA-1 tone rather than just doing the same as the bass and treble on the amp. Granted, it all sort of works together and in some ways, there is more than one way to get to the same end result. In general though, there is something different about the sound I get when using the FA-1. Maybe I'll post a clip. What I really need to do is take my FA-1 into a shop and test it with a real AC30 to hear for myself how the sound compares to what I get on my amp. Then I'll know if it's adding any value to my overall sound.


Posted 1 year ago

 

 

My understanding of the amp's circuitry is this: The MV controls the amount of signal to the power amp section, which includes the tube and the PL is an attenuator just before the speaker. The headphone output comes right after the MV but before the rest of the power amp, which is just for the speaker. So the problem you are experiencing, therefore, could come from any component or connection that comes after the MV and headphone jack.

I always set my PL and MV to my preferred spots and then use Volume to adjust loudness. If I then need more, I can boost the MV and/or PL, but in that case, the hiss won't be an issue as my need for that much volume would be because I'm playing with other loud instruments, so the hiss would be drowned out. The only noise issue I have now with either of my amps is power amp hiss on the VT20+.

If the PL operates smoothly and without noise or peaks and dropouts, it's probably OK, but I'd spray it anyway.

Re: speaker connectors - I wouldn't replace them, just make sure they have been cleaned, lubed and reattached several times to scrape off whatever gunk may be there, and make sure the final connection is nice and firm, not flaccid and wobbly (did I just say that?) ;-o

As you have pointed out, there doesn't seem to be any one cause for the snare noise, other than, in the experience of myself and various others, a poor connection somewhere.

Since you mentioned shipping on the other thread, does that mean you are not near a dealer where you try out some other samples of this amp? If you can, I would advise that - see if you can find one that isn't doing what's bothering you about this one - and maker sure you set it up identically. Bring your own amp in to do a side by side comparison.


Posted 1 year ago

 

wbesack

Member

 

Nothing worse than a flaccid wobbly connection. I hate when that happens. LOL! Thanks for the explanation of the various components and their order in the chain.

The shop I bought this one from does not have another. I have a Guitar Center in town that used to have one on their demo floor. I've got another shop in town that caries Vox but they didn't have one either last time I checked.

The shipping I referred to was directly to Korg USA when my first one died. I had dropped the dead one off at the local authorized dealer for service. After waiting in cue for 3 weeks they informed me that Korg does not repair this line of Valvetronix. It was somewhat "disposable" and considered a "non-serviceable" item. My only option was to, at my expense, ship it to Korg. It was expensive but as I said, once they got it, they shipped me a brand new unit in a couple of days with brand new warranty. If I find one locally to compare it to, I may be doing this again. At that point, I may just sell the replacement as "NEW" and buy a used VT30.

If I can find one, I'll take my guitar, amp, and cable to the shop. I'll document the settings as well. I do computer and systems troubleshooting for a living so know the importance of methodical elimination and setting variables consistently.

As others have posted, I sure wish I could just open this thing up and find something obvious like a bulging capacitor or loose connection. In my case, not so much.


Posted 1 year ago

 

lusthaben

Member

 

Holy Cow! I can't believe that Korg would define the VT+ series as disposable! That doesn't say much for how Vox values the most recent series of Valvetronix amps they have released, if true.

You heard this from an authorized service representative, not from Vox. . .I would like to hear a comment from a Vox representative on this forum.


Posted 1 year ago

 

wbesack

Member

 

Yes, my local dealer used the word disposable, then corrected themselves with the official phrase of "non-field serviceable" even though my amp tech could probably build it from scratch. The last time they serviced my old AD15VT and had no issues doing so. Must be a change in Korg policy with the new line. He wasn't really even allowed to look at it, or at least, Korg wasn't willing to pay him to do a level 1 assessment, even to determine if it was something as simple as a blown fuse.


Posted 1 year ago

 

 

Voxman, any comment on this?


Posted 1 year ago

 

voxman

VOX Forum Moderator

voxman
 

I think what the Vox dealers might be referring to is what might be better described as 'beyond economical repair'.

If you take a VT20+ for example, Vox has squeezed a load of technology/options/tone into a very compact and very competitively priced unit. Because this is a 'mass market' product, and Vox are trying to be as competitive as possible, there probably isn't a huge mark-up. Now that's good news for consumers, and at £120 or so, a VT20+ represents stonking bang for your buck! Remember, these are made in China to benefit from lower manufacturing costs (eg labour) compared to US/UK.

But if anything breaks down, unless it's easy to identify and fix, the chances are that home country labour costs (which will be way higher than those for production costs in China) will be way more. I'm guessing that a qualified electrical engineer probably costs circa £40 an hour - so if (for example) the real net manufacturing cost of the VT20+ before marketing, distribution, retail profit, etc is say £60 (purely an example - I have no inside pricing knowledge) it's probably cheaper for Vox (& faster for the customer) just to replace the amp under warranty.

The Valvetronix is arguably as much computer as it is guitar amp, and it's exactly the same with modern day IT gear - nowadays if your graphics card or hard drive goes, its cheaper to replace than try & repair. So, we are now living in an ever more disposable world - when I bought my DVD player it was £165. I can now buy a DVD player for £25 with better spec or a more up-to-date Blue Ray player for £65!! Repair just doesn't make sense anymore for a lot of goods and it is ever-increasingly just a fact of life now.

Rich


Posted 1 year ago

 

RSS feed for this topic

 

You must be logged in to post.